The front-runner in the race to replace Nancy Pelosi spent the week asking for more stages to stand on. State Senator Scott Wiener, fresh off a comfortable June primary win, challenged Supervisor Connie Chan on Wednesday to fifteen debates before November — one in each of San Francisco's ten supervisorial districts, plus five single-issue forums. It is the move of a candidate who wants the contest defined on his terms, early and often.
Chan's campaign passed. They weren't interested in Wiener's particular proposal, her team said, and would instead work with the community groups and newsrooms already lining up to host their own forums.
The optics are worth sitting with. The establishment pick, the better-funded campaign, the man with Sacramento's machinery behind him — and he is the one demanding the debates. Front-runners who feel safe do not ask for fifteen of anything.
Two days later came a different kind of forum. A video posted Friday by activist Dimitry Yakoushkin, and shared thousands of times, shows marchers confronting Wiener at San Francisco's Trans March. "For the first time we kicked his ass out," Yakoushkin wrote, describing the senator as "walking away defeated." The Dissent could not independently verify the full exchange, and Wiener's office did not immediately respond to a request for comment. But the clip — a Democratic legislator with one of the longest pro-LGBTQ records in the state, jeered off the lawn at a queer march he has marched in for years — captures something the polling hasn't caught up to yet.
Because the thing eroding Wiener's left flank isn't his record on housing or trans rights. It's Gaza.
For months, Wiener would not say the word. At a January candidate forum's lightning round, asked to hold up a "yes" or "no" sign to whether Israel was committing genocide, Chan and Saikat Chakrabarti raised theirs. Wiener put his down. Days later, on social media, he reversed course: "I've stopped short of calling it genocide, but I can't anymore."
To his supporters, that was a thoughtful man arriving at a hard conclusion in real time. To his critics, the timing said everything. "People getting killed didn't move him, but boos at a forum did," Chan spokesperson Julie Edwards put it.
That ambiguity — the sense that Wiener's positions arrive a beat after the room demands them — is becoming the through-line of the race. It's why a debate challenge can read less like confidence than like an attempt to change the subject, and why a heckle at the Trans March travels faster than any endorsement. The picture is messier than either camp lets on: Mission Local has reported that some of Chan's own big backers carry ties to pro-Israel PACs, a wrinkle her supporters dispute.
None of this means Wiener loses. He won the primary handily; Chan placed second, with Pelosi's endorsement, into a one-on-one general, and he remains the favorite. But favorites get to choose the ground they fight on only as long as their base lets them. Right now Scott Wiener is asking for fifteen debates. The harder question — the one the clip from Dolores Park asks for him — is whether he can still walk into a march in his own city without being asked to leave.
The Discussion
Loading…